Below is an email that I sent to Kerry Smith, the Senior Vice President for Editorial Quality at ABC news, back in November of 2016.
She did not reply..
Dear Ms. Smith,
I am a professor of economics specialized in the quantitative analysis of armed conflict. I have a big body of work focused on data quality issues that arise during data collection in conflict zones, especially survey data.
Back in 2011 I wrote a paper with Steven Koczela, now a prominent pollster with MassINC Polling, that uncovered substantial evidence of fabricated data in polls fielded in Iraq by D3 Systems. We sent our paper to various interested parties for comments, including Mathew Warshaw of D3 Systems and Gary Langer who had just moved from ABC to found Langer Associates. We included Mr. Langer in the circulation list because ABC news had used D3 Systems for a series of polls in Iraq that now required urgent re-evaluation.
D3, backed by Langer Associates, responded by threatening to sue me and Mr. Koczela. See this, this and this. My university has supported me against this censorship attempt but, unfortunately, Mr. Koczela felt that he could not defend himself and signed an agreement to keep his mouth shut about this particular piece of work. (This why only my name appears on the first link above.) Eventually, the legal threat disappeared when I wrote to Mr. Warshaw asking him explain what, specifically, he objected to in our analysis. He did not reply.
To his credit Mr. Koczela continued working on this issue, unearthing a large number of datasets for opinion polls conducted in Iraq by D3 Systems and other polling companies. These have provided remarkably strong evidence of data fabrication already. For example, see this eye-popping analysis.
Many of the D3 Iraq surveys that I now have were conducted for the US State Department. Mr. Koczela made the State Department aware of the problem at some point and they hired Fritz Scheuren, a former president of the American Statistical Association to investigate. His analysis confirmed the fabrication problem using an analysis rather different from mine. Unfortunately, Dr. Scheuren signed a nondisclosure agreement but I believe he would confirm in general terms the main gist of this work and he could also give you an authoritative opinion on my analysis. (email@example.com)
Notice that after the Huffington Post article Langer Associates did post a response to my 2011 paper. This is, however, exceptionally weak as I explain in these articles. Langer Associates have not addressed the new evidence that has emerged since Mr Koczela’s FOIA either.
I emailed Mr. Langer for the data from the ABC Iraq polls but he did not reply. I asked Mr. Warshaw for the same data and he referred me to ABC news. I am now requesting the data from you.
At the risk of belabouring the obvious, I note that people with strong intellectual cases to make do not start by threatening to sue and finish by withholding their data.
Most importantly, ABC needs to take action to correct the historical record of the Iraq war. These polling numbers are all over the web sites of ABC news and its partner organizations in these polls. This work must be retracted.
It is, of course, your journalistic obligation to correct the historical record but, at the same time, I think it’s to your advantage to do so. Fixing this problem would demonstrate a strong commitment to quality and accuracy. I doubt you would even lose your Emmy Award. Surely you won’t be punished for pursuing the truth wherever it leads. I will do anything I can to help in this regard.
I suggest that we meet to discuss these issues further. I would be happy to fly to New York at my own expense for this purpose. Alternatively, we could talk by phone, skype or some other technology.
Professor Michael Spagat
Head of Department
Department of Economics
Royal Holloway College
University of London
Egham, Surrey TW20 0EX
+44 1784 414001
+44 1784 439534 (F)
War, Numbers and Human Losses: The Truth Counts