Secret Data Sunday – Gary Langer Edition

Last Sunday I shared an unanswered email I had sent to the Senior Vice President for Editorial Quality at ABC news.  The email gives a self-contained account of the overall context behind my data request, but I’ll take another pass here just to be as clear as possible.

There were a remarkable number of opinion polls conducted in Iraq during the US occupation.  Many of these were fielded by D3 Systems working with KA Research Limited.  Steve Koczela and I analyzed some of these surveys and found extensive evidence of fabricated data.  We wrote up our findings and asked for comments from interested parties.  D3 and Langer Research Associates then threatened to sue us rather than constructively engaging.  (See this, this and this.)

It’s clear that Langer Research Associates reacted so furiously because Gary Langer did a series of D3-KA Iraq polls for ABC  that won an Emmy Award plus the Policy Impact Award from the American Association for Public Opinion Research.  So he has a lot at stake.

Moreover, the write ups of these ABC polls show that the ABC data display some of the same patterns that Steve and I found in other D3-KA-Iraq polls.  One of the big ones is  opinion unanimity in certain governorates, including Anbar, that is more characteristic of robots than it is of human beings.  With this in mind, check out the highlighted text below.

^2284C743C86CC164FCB2B2EF819738398CF6E4E396A18B028B^pimgpsh_fullsize_distr

^E277C881426EB61DB031A34F3791226CA4761A05985A3642E9^pimgpsh_fullsize_distr

Given this background it is, perhaps, not surprising that D3 and Langer went for a legal choke-slam rather than for serious discussion.  Nevertheless, it is disappointing that these research organizations place so little value on the truth.  Thus, there really must be an outside examination of the micro data from ABC’s public opinion polling in Iraq.

I requested the data from Mathew Warshaw of D3 Systems.  He directed me to ABC News.  But, as we know, ABC News ignored my data request.  I also tried Gary Langer who  ignored me at first but finally wrote back on my latest attempt.

This is what I wrote to Langer.

Gary,

This is an opportune moment to renew my data request for the surveys you conducted in Iraq using D3 Systems and KA Research Limited.  You did not reply to my last request.

You abdigate your responsibility to the truth and violate principles of transparency by hiding your data and trying to shut down discussion of your work.

Mike Spagat

This is his reply.

Jeez, you really know how to sweet talk a guy, don’t you?

Extra points for “abdigate.”

OK, I accept full responsibility for misspelling abdicate…..abdicate, abdicate, abdicate, abdigate  gah! dammit….

I’m less apologetic about not being sweeter about my request.  Maybe being sweet is better than not being sweet but, in the end, he should live up to his responsibilities whether or not people talk to him sweetly.

Strangely this isn’t the end of the story but you’ll have to come back next Sunday for more.

Advertisements

One thought on “Secret Data Sunday – Gary Langer Edition

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s